With Her Job on the Line, Nicola Sturgeon of Scotland Hits Back at Critics


LONDON — Accused of lying, breaking official rules and conspiring against her predecessor, Alex Salmond, First Minister Nicola Sturgeon of Scotland fought back hard Wednesday against allegations that have cast a shadow over her future and over the prospects for Scottish independence.

In nearly eight tense hours of testimony before the Scottish Parliament, Ms. Sturgeon denied plotting against Mr. Salmond or breaching ministerial rules during a botched internal investigation of sexual harassment allegations against him.

Opponents had called for Ms. Sturgeon’s resignation even before she spoke, but on Wednesday she appealed to lawmakers to trust her account of a bewildering sequence of events. And she rejected what she called the “absurd suggestion that anyone acted with malice or as part of a plot against Alex Salmond.”

Ms. Sturgeon also went on the attack, pointedly criticizing her predecessor’s failure to acknowledge last week, in his evidence to the same committee, that he had behaved inappropriately toward women.

“I know from what he told me that his behavior was not always appropriate and yet, across six hours of testimony, there was not a single word of regret, reflection or even simple acknowledgment of that,” she said.

Wednesday’s session was the culmination an extraordinary feud between Ms. Sturgeon and Mr. Salmond, her mentor and direct predecessor as Scotland’s first minister — a dispute so bitter that it could wreck Ms. Sturgeon’s career and set back the cause of Scottish independence to which both politicians devoted their lives.

Mr. Salmond spotted Ms. Sturgeon’s talent as a student politician and made her his deputy in 2004, a position in which she served for a decade before assuming the top job when her boss quit after Scots voted against independence in a 2014 referendum.

But the rupture between the two biggest figures in Scottish politics, with its almost Shakespearean claims of conspiracy and betrayal, comes just as the prospects for Scottish independence have begun to shine brightly once again because of Brexit, which is highly unpopular in Scotland.

The dispute revolves around an internal investigation in 2018 of two complaints against Mr. Salmond dating from 2013. Mr. Salmond argued that the inquiry process was flawed, took the Scottish government to court and won, with Scottish taxpayers paying his legal fees of more than £500,000. When the police later took up a criminal case against him Mr. Salmond was acquitted of 13 charges including one of attempted rape.

Now determined to salvage his reputation, Mr. Salmond argues that those close to Ms. Sturgeon had conspired against him to prevent his return to politics after he lost his seat in the British Parliament in 2017 — and were even willing to see him jailed. Last week he also said that Scotland’s political leadership and institutions had failed under his successor, a claim that seemed to undermine the case for independence.

But more dangerous for Ms. Sturgeon are allegations that she misled the Scottish Parliament over what she knew and when, and over how she handled the sexual harassment complaints.

Ms. Sturgeon faces two inquiries and, if she is judged clearly to have lied, she would be expected to quit under the nation’s strict ministerial rules. Even if she survives, as many believe she will, the timing is terrible, coming ahead of elections to the Scottish Parliament in May.

In that vote Ms. Sturgeon hopes for gains for her party that she can use to justify holding a second referendum on Scottish independence.

But instead of campaigning, Ms. Sturgeon was on Wednesday battling to save her job with a fluent performance, albeit without satisfying her critics.

In occasionally spiky exchanges, Ms. Sturgeon presented her actions as those of a politician torn between personal loyalty to her mentor and a stronger determination not to tolerate sexual harassment.

“As first minister I refused to follow the age-old pattern of allowing a powerful man to use his status and his connections to get what he wants,” she said.

As for the claims against her, Ms. Sturgeon said she had “searched my soul on all of this many, many, times over,” but added that “in one of the most invidious personal and political situations I have ever faced I believe I acted properly and appropriately and that overall I made the best judgments I could.”

Ms. Sturgeon acknowledged mistakes in the 2018 investigation and apologized to the two complainants.

But she has made errors of her own since then. Ms. Sturgeon initially said she first heard about the allegations against Mr. Salmond on April 2, 2018, during a meeting with him at her home, but later admitted that she had been given some earlier warning by his former chief of staff, Geoff Aberdein, on March 29.

On Wednesday, Ms. Sturgeon said she had gleaned only a vague understanding of what was at stake during the March 29 meeting, and that learning about the accusations in detail on April 2 was…

Read More:With Her Job on the Line, Nicola Sturgeon of Scotland Hits Back at Critics

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.